Israel is Committing "Ethnic Cleansing and War Crimes in Gaza" according to Israel's own former Defense Minister/ NYT
To all the IDF troll farmers, you can stop piling on with your cries of antisemitism now. The Jewish State became Nazi Germany, so horrific that few can get their heads out of the sand and believe it
By Adam RasgonLiam Stack and Natan Odenheimer
Reporting from Jerusalem and Tel Aviv
Dec. 1, 2024
A former Israeli defense minister has accused Israel of committing war crimes and ethnic cleansing in the Gaza Strip, a rare critique from a member of the security establishment at a time of war.
The comments by Moshe Yaalon — first on Saturday, and then multiple times on Sunday, including in an interview with one of Israel’s biggest television channels — came amid mounting criticism of the Israeli military’s conduct in Gaza. They were swiftly denied and condemned by allies of Prime Minister Benjamin Netanyahu of Israel, saying that they would hurt the country and help its enemies.
Mr. Yaalon served as the Israeli military’s chief of staff during the second intifada and as Mr. Netanyahu’s defense minister during the 2014 war in Gaza, the longest conflict between Israel and Hamas before the current war. [In other words, he knows what he is talking about—Nass]
But he broke with Mr. Netanyahu in 2016 and has since become a critic of the Israeli leader.
At an event on Saturday, Mr. Yaalon denounced Mr. Netanyahu’s government for its actions in Gaza.
“The path they’re dragging us down is to occupy, annex, and ethnically cleanse — look at the northern strip,” he said. He also said Israel was being pulled in the direction of building settlements in Gaza, a notion that is supported by far-right politicians in Mr. Netanyahu’s government.
When the interviewer at the event asked Mr. Yaalon to clarify whether he thought Israel was on the way to carrying out ethnic cleansing, he responded: “Why on the way? What’s happening there? What’s happening there?”
“There’s no Beit Lahia. There’s no Beit Hanoun. They’re now operating in Jabaliya. They’re basically cleaning the territory of Arabs,” he said, referring to towns and cities in northern Gaza where a renewed Israeli offensive against the militant group Hamas has caused extensive damage in recent months. Tens of thousands of Palestinians have been killed in Gaza since the war began in response to the deadly Hamas-led attack on Israel in October 2023.
Mr. Yaalon doubled down on his accusations on Sunday, saying on public radio that Mr. Netanyahu’s government was exposing Israeli commanders to lawsuits at the International Criminal Court and was putting their lives at risk.
“I’m speaking in the name of IDF commanders who are operating in the northern strip,” Mr. Yaalon told the Reshet Bet radio station. “They reached out to me expressing fear about what’s happening there.” [In other words, the brass are being told to commit war crimes, and they know what they are doing—Nass]
He later said, in an apparent reference to the government: “At the end of the day, they’re perpetrating war crimes” — while making clear that his issue was not with the soldiers themselves.
In another interview, broadcast Sunday night, he stood behind his remarks yet again and even said he no longer says Israel has the most moral army in the world, a claim often promulgated by defenders of the country.
“It’s hard for me to say this,” he told the Israeli broadcaster Channel 12, adding that Israel’s political leadership was “corrupting the military.” He said the military was ordering the evacuation of towns, believing the move was for operational reasons. But, he suggested, some of Israel’s political leaders actually intend to clear the area for settlements.
The Israeli military declined to comment on Mr. Yaalon’s accusations, which came 10 days after the International Criminal Court issued arrest warrants for Mr. Netanyahu and Yoav Gallant, his former defense minister, for crimes against humanity and war crimes in Gaza.
Mr. Netanyahu’s office has rejected the accusations against the men in the warrants, calling them “absurd and false” and accusing the court of being motivated by antisemitism.
Mr. Yaalon’s comments were condemned by Mr. Netanyahu’s Likud party, of which Mr. Yaalon is a former member.
“Yaalon already lost his way a long time ago,” the party said in a statement. “His defamatory words are a prize for the International Criminal Court and the haters of Israel camp. Israel is fighting back against a murderous terrorist group that carried out mass slaughter.”
Mr. Gallant said on Sunday that Mr. Yaalon’s statements were “a lie that aids our enemy and harms Israel.”
The Israeli military “acted according to the highest standards that can be applied in the complex and difficult war that was imposed on us,” Mr. Gallant said in a post on social media. “The instructions and commands were always given in accordance with the law.”
Israel’s communications minister, Shlomo Karhi, said Mr. Yaalon “crossed all the red lines.” while Tally Gotliv, a firebrand Likud lawmaker, called him “worse than our biggest enemies.”
Israel has called on Palestinians from the northernmost reaches of Gaza to evacuate on several occasions since the war began last fall, including in the first week of the conflict and again in October. Tens of thousands of people have heeded those warnings and fled, but many are believed to have remained in the area, either because they cannot or do not want to leave.
Mr. Yaalon’s statements were striking because they come at a time in which Israelis from across the political spectrum have united in their opposition to the I.C.C.’s issuing of the warrants for Mr. Netanyahu and Mr. Gallant.
When asked if the warrant for Mr. Netanyahu was justified in the Sunday night interview, Mr. Yaalon said he didn’t want to be the judge of that, but he did not denounce it. He added, “I think, on a moral level, that a few things happened here that aren’t good from our perspective.”
They were also unusual because Israelis and their leaders — like people in many countries — tend to rally around the troops during a time of war. Criticism by former Israeli officials of the war has tended to focus on strategy or whether to agree to a cease-fire with Hamas, not the military’s conduct veering into potential war crimes.
Of four former senior Israeli security officials contacted by The Times on Sunday, only one agreed to comment.
Ami Ayalon, the former director of the Shin Bet domestic intelligence agency who has criticized Mr. Netanyahu in the past, said he wasn’t sure whether Israel’s actions in Gaza met the legal definition of “ethnic cleansing.” But he described the Israeli government’s policy directives for the military as “immoral and unjust,” saying they could expose commanders and soldiers to prosecution by the International Criminal Court.
In recent months, aid organizations and world leaders, including President Biden, have warned of a humanitarian catastrophe in North Gaza. During that time, Israel has allowed little humanitarian aid to enter. Last month, Israel banned imports of commercial goods, saying that Hamas was benefiting from their sale. North Gaza is the northernmost of Gaza’s five governorates.
Israeli officials have said that Palestinians from North Gaza will be able to return to their homes after the war. Mr. Netanyahu has dismissed the idea of building settlements in Gaza, but hard-line members of his right-wing coalition have advocated for it.
Some Israelis worry that Mr. Netanyahu’s indecision about plans for postwar Gaza could result in a long-term occupation of the enclave, leaving open the possibility for right-wing members of the coalition to advance their ambitions to build settlements.
Some Palestinians from Gaza also took note of Mr. Yaalon’s comments.
Akram Atallah, a Palestinian columnist originally from Jabaliya, said he considered Mr. Yaalon’s remarks to be “extremely important.”
“This remark strengthens the Palestinian narrative of what is happening in Gaza,” he said. “And it isn’t coming from an Arab official or a sympathetic member of the international community. It’s coming from someone who was a general at the top of the Israeli system.”
If you aren’t already a paid subscriber to our Substack, we have some great perks to say THANK YOU!
Go Paid at the $5 a month level and get a copy of “Government” - The Biggest Scam in History… Exposed! in PDF & ePub & the links to download our Flashdrive O’ Freedom: The Liberator for Free over Dropbox
Go Paid OR Upgrade to the $50 Yearly Membership and get a free paperback edition of “Government” OR get a free credit card-sized Liberator flash drive including S&H domestic U.S.A. If you are international, you get the same premium with a $10 S&H credit, and we will e-mail you a quote on getting the physical book or drive.
“Go Paid” or Upgrade to the $250 Founding Member Level and get an Everything Bundle, including a signed high-resolution hardcover edition of “Government” and a paperback edition of Voluntaryism – How the Only “ISM” Fair for Everyone Leads to Harmony, Prosperity and Good Karma for All when published in Dec/Jan - delivered anywhere in the world!
Already a Founding Member? Consider becoming an Art of Liberty Foundation yearly sponsor! We have some great perks to say THANK YOU including the opportunity to host an Art of Liberty Foundation event & party in your town to introduce your friends and family to voluntaryism! ArtOfLiberty.org/Sponsor
No, Etienne. The push to suggest Israel is guilty of ethnic cleansing while not mentioning the rest of the world's issues is just another form of antisemitism. Comparing Israel to Nazi Germany is absurd. Germany essentially outlawed sectors of their population, Jews most notably, and waged war against an amalgam of craftsmen and shopkeepers who had no way to resist. They were herded off to death camps and systematically slaughtered by the most brutally efficient murder machine that has ever existed. Israel is responding to the constant attacks since 2023 with security measure that require movement of people for their own safety. Their lack of food is on the extant members of HAMAS, not deliberate attempts to starve them.
I read the hammering against Israel here, yet nothing about how Arab militias are raping, murdering and forcefully relocating non-Arabs in West Darfur. Or the continued war crimes in Myanmar, or as Human Watch notes: "For more than a year and a half, a largely invisible campaign of ethnic cleansing has played out in Ethiopia’s northern region of Tigray. Older people, women, and children have been loaded onto trucks and forced out of their villages and hometowns. Men have been herded into overcrowded detention sites, where many have died of disease, starvation, or torture. In total, several hundred thousand Tigrayans have been forcibly uprooted because of their ethnicity."
Meanwhile, in Bangladesh, "a repressive government with no opposition runs the Rapid Action Battalion, which is under sanctions by the United States government, but security forces remain implicated in torture, killings, and enforced disappearances. The government arrested journalists and critics, and stifled civil society."
In Syria, In Idlib, despite a recent ceasefire, the Syrian-Russian military alliance still poses a threat to over 3 million civilians trapped there, while the dominant Islamist armed group, Hay’et Tahrir al-Sham, restricts their freedoms. In Turkish-occupied territories, Turkey and local factions are abusing civilians’ rights with impunity.